Law Library
Rajkishore Purohit vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. [01.08.2017]ย Coram: Ranjan Gogoi & Navin Sinha, JJ.
Criminal Appeal by SLP-Section 302/34 IPC & 25(1)(a) of the Arms Act– Common Intention-Appeal against acquittal by the brother of the deceased-ย Common intention is a state of mind. It is not possible to read aย personโs mind. There can hardly be direct evidence of commonย intention. The existence or non-existence of a common intentionย amongst the accused has to be deciphered cumulatively from theirย conduct and behavior in the facts and circumstances of each case.ย Events prior to the occurrence as also after, and during theย occurrence, are all relevant to deduce if there existed any commonย intention. There can be no straight jacket formula. The absence of anyย overt act of assault, exhortation or possession of weapon cannot beย singularly determinative of absence of common intention-
Article 136 of the Constitution-Though this Court, in exercise of discretionary jurisdiction underย Article 136 of the Constitution, may not interfere with an order ofย acquittal, reversing a conviction, yet if it finds that the High Court hasย completely erred in appreciation of evidence, has applied the wrongย principles to negate common intention, and has based its conclusionsย on speculative reasoning, beyond the defence of the accused himself,ย justice will demand that the acquittal is reversed.ย
Central Bureau of Investigation vs. M. Sivamani [01.08.2017]ย ย Coram: Adarsh Kumar Goel & Uday Umesh Lalit, JJ.
whether there is non-compliance of Sectionย 195(1)(a)(i) CrPC in court taking cognizance of the offence inย question , i.e. Section 182 IPC
Criminal -Appeal against ย HC quashed the proceedings-False Motorย Accident Claim-under Sections 120-B r/w 182, 420, 468,ย 468 r/w 471 IPC and 13(2) r/w 13(i)(d)of ย Prevention of Corruptionย Act, 1988 r/w 511 IPC-Section 195(1) CrPC -While the barย against cognizance of a specified offence is mandatory, the same ย ย has to be understood in the context of the purpose for which suchย a bar is created. The bar is not intended to take away remedyย against a crime but only to protect an innocent person againstย false or frivolous proceedings by a private person. The expressionย โthe public servant or his administrative superiorโ cannot excludeย the High Court. It is clearly implicit in the direction of the Highย Court quoted above that it was necessary in the interest of justiceย to take cognizance of the offence in question. Direction of theย High Court is at par with the direction of an administrativeย superior public servant to file a complaint in writing in terms ofย the statutory requirement. The protection intended by theย Section against a private person filing a frivolous complaint isย taken care of when the High Court finds that the matter wasย required to be gone into in public interest. Such direction cannotย be rendered futile by invoking Section 195 to such a situation.ย Once the High Court directs investigation into a specified offenceย mentioned in Section 195, bar under Section 195(1)(a) cannot beย pressed into service. The view taken by the High Court willย frustrate the object of law and cannot be sustained.
Glocal Medical College and Super Speciality Hospital & Research Centre vs. Union of India & Anr. [01.08.2017]
Coram: Dipak Misra, Amitava Roy & A. M. Khanwilkar, JJ.
IQ City Foundation & Anr. vs. Union of India & Ors. [01.08.2017]ย Coram: Dipak Misra, Amitava Roy & A. M. Khanwilkar, JJ.
Article 32-Section 10-A of the Indianย Medical Council Act, 1956-writ of certiorari-On a reading of Section 10-A of the Act, Rules and theย Regulations, as has been referred to in Manohar Lalย Sharma (supra), and the view expressed in Royal Medicalย Trust (supra), it would be inapposite to restrict the power ofย the MCI by laying down as an absolute principle that onceย the Central Government sends back the matter to MCI forย compliance verification and the Assessors visit the Collegeย they shall only verify the mentioned items and turn aย Nelsonโs eye even if they perceive certain other deficiencies.ย It would be playing possum. The direction of the Centralย Government for compliance verification report should not beย construed as a limited remand as is understood within theย framework of Code of Civil Procedure or any other law. Theย distinction between the principles of open remand andย limited remand, we are disposed to think, is not attracted.ย Be it clearly stated, the said principle also does not flowย from the authority in Royal Medical Trust (supra). In thisย context, the objectivity of the Hearing Committee and theย role of the Central Government assume great significance.ย The real compliant institutions should not always be keptย under the sword of Damocles. Stability can be brought byย affirmative role played by the Central Government. And theย stability and objectivity would be perceptible if reasons areย ascribed while expressing a view and absence of reasonsย makes the decision sensitively susceptible.
ย ยฉAdvocatetanmoy Law library


More Stories
Title 2 โ The Congress (U.S. State Code): Congress, Elections, Committees, Budget and Congressional Administration
1 U.S. Code Sec 1 – Words denoting number, gender, and so forth
Title 1 – General Provisions (U.S. State Code): General Provisions, Statutory Construction and Codification