ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป Despite settlement quashing of FIR when to be declined

Despite settlement quashing of FIR when to be declined

 

TagTagline: Even whenย there is a settlement, the view of the offender and victim will not prevail sinceย it is in the interest of society that the offender should be punished to deterย others from committing a similar crime.

Forย that matter the offence that has the potentiality to create a dentย in the financial health of the institutions, is not to be quashed onย the ground that there is delay in trial or the principle that whenย the matter has been settled it should be quashed to avoid theย load on the system

High Court was justified into entertain the application for quashing the First Information Reportin the exercise of its inherent jurisdiction. The High Court has adverted to twosignificant circumstances. Each of them has a bearing on whether theexercise of the jurisdiction under Section 482 to quash the FIR wouldor secure the ends of justice or prevent an abuse of the process of the court. The first is that the appellants were absconding and warrants hadย been issued against them under Section 70 of the Code of Criminalย Procedure, 1973. The second is that the appellants have criminalย antecedents, reflected in the chart which has been extracted in the earlier partย of this judgment. The High Court adverted to the modus operandi which hadย been followed by the appellants in grabbing valuable parcels of land andย noted that in the past as well, they were alleged to have been connected withย such nefarious activities by opening bogus bank accounts. It was in this viewย of the matter that the High Court observed that in a case involving extortion,ย forgery and conspiracy where all the appellants were acting as a team, it was
not in the interest of society to quash the FIR on the ground that a settlementย had been arrived at with the complainant. We agree with the view of the Highย Court. The present case, as the allegations in the FIR would demonstrate, isย not merely one involving a private dispute over a land transaction betweenย two contesting parties. The case involves allegations of extortion, forgery andย fabrication of documents, utilization of fabricated documents to effectuateย transfers of title before the registering authorities and the deprivation of theย complainant of his interest in land on the basis of a fabricated power ofย attorney. If the allegations in the FIR are construed as they stand, it is evidentย that they implicate serious offences having a bearing on a vital societalย interest in securing the probity of titles to or interest in land. Such offencesย cannot be construed to be merely private or civil disputes but implicate theย societal interest in prosecuting serious crime. In these circumstances, theย High Court was eminently justified in declining to quash the FIR which hadย been registered under Sections 384, 467, 468, 471, 120-B and 506(2) of the
Penal Code.

Ref : [ ย October 04, 2017ย PARBATBHAI AAHIR @ PARBATBHAIย BHIMSINHBHAI KARMUR AND ORS ย VSย STATE OF GUJARAT AND ANR]