ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป Nemo dat quod non habet means “no one gives what he doesn’t have”

Nemo dat quod non habet means “no one gives what he doesn’t have”

“Nemo plus iuris ad alium transferre potest quam ipse habet” rule, which means “one cannot transfer more rights than he has”

Supreme Court of India inย The Morvi Mercantile Bank Ltd. And … vs Union Of India, Through The [ 1965ย AIR 1954 ]

 

To the general rule expressed by the Maxim nemoย dat quod non habet (no one can convey a better title thanย what he had), to facilitate mercantile transactions. theย Indian Law has grafted some exceptions, in favour ofย bonafide pledgees by transfer of documents of title fromย persons. whether owners of goods who do not possess the fullย bundle of rights of ownership at the time the pledges areย made, or their mercantile agents. To confer a right toย effect a valid pledge by transfer of document of titleย relating to goods on persons with defects in their titleย to the goods. and on mercantile agents, and to deny it toย the full owners thereof, is to introduce an incongruity intoย the Act. On the other hand, the real intention of theย legislature will be carried out if the said right isย conceded to the Full owner of goods and extended byย construction to persons with defects in their title to theย goods or to mercantile agents. A pledge being a bailment ofย goods under s. 172 of the Contract Act, the pledgee, as aย bailee. will have the same remedies as the owner of theย goods would have against a third person for deprivation of
the said goods or injury to them under s. 180 of the Act.

Indianย  Contractย  Act (9 of 1872), s.ย  178, Transferย  ofย Indianย  Contractย  Act (9 of 1872), s.ย  178, Transferย  ofPropertyย  Act (4 of 1882). ss. 4 and 137 and Indian Saleย  of goodsย  Act (3 of 1930), ss. 30 and 53


Compare

Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) USA

Courts of equity[USA]

Sale of Goods Act 1979[UK]