ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Law Library ยป Vivekananda was a rascal, and he had no knowledge: AC Bhaktivedanta Prabhupada

Vivekananda was a rascal, and he had no knowledge: AC Bhaktivedanta Prabhupada

On December 11, 1971 in New Delhi, AC Bhaktivedanta criticized materialistic persons' imperfect vision and speculative theories. He argued that imperfect senses cannot lead to perfect knowledge, challenging astronomers and scientists. He described different types of conditioned souls - good, passionate, and rascal. He also criticized Vivekananda and Karpatri for their imperfect conclusions despite their knowledge. Bhakti-yoga, according to him, cleanses the mind and intelligence, allowing one to see the Supreme Personality of Godhead and maya. He emphasized the power of bhakti-yoga in revealing all knowledge.

Date: (11/12/1971)

Room Conversation — December 11, 1971, New Delhi

Vivekananda was actually a rascal, and he had no knowledge – AC Bhaktivedanta

A room conversation in New Delhi on December 11, 1971, in which A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, founder of ISKCON, criticized the philosophical views of Swami Vivekananda (Narendra Nath Datta).

Srila Prabhupฤda:

samyak praแน‡ihite ‘male
apaล›yat puruแนฃaแน pลซrแน‡aแน
mฤyฤแน ca tad-apฤล›rayam
(SB 1.7.4)

The materialistic person, they have only one experience: this cosmic manifestation. Beyond this, they have no other vision. Their senses are imperfect. Just like the astronomers, they have got big, big telescope, many other instruments. They want to see through the eyes how many stars are there, how the planets are moving, and whatever imperfect knowledge they receive, by that little knowledge they advertise themselves as great scientists.

But they do not calculate that, “We are trying to see the stars and planets with powerful binoculars. That means our eyes are imperfect.” And what is the guarantee that the instruments which they’re using, they are also perfect? Because that machine, that binocular, is also made by a person who is imperfect.

So what is the guarantee that by seeing through binocular or microscope, the conclusion arrived, it is perfect? What is your answer? Your eyes are imperfect, that’s a fact. Otherwise, why you are using binocular, microscope? Eyes are imperfect.

Originally your eyes are imperfect. Now, eyes or other senses, it doesn’t matter. Sense is sense. So you are manufacturing a machine, some instrument, by the same imperfect senses, then what is the guarantee that this machine, this binocular, if you see through the binocular, the knowledge is perfect? What is your answer?

Devotee: Can’t be perfect.

Prabhupฤda: Answer? Anyone other?

Devotee (2): Perfect knowledge cannot be received with imperfect senses. Only through perfect senses can perfect knowledge be received.

Prabhupฤda: Therefore it should be concluded that the so-called scientists, astronomers, they are all imperfect, and they are passing on the scientists as learned. So you can challenge them, “What is the guarantee that your knowledge is perfect?” Actually, it is not. They do not know how the stars are moving. They are always imperfect, simply putting some theories. They say all this, Darwin’s theory and this theory, that theory. They are simply speculating on imperfect senses, and therefore they’re cheating, because the conditioned soul has got a tendency to cheat others.

If one can cheat others, he thinks himself as very intelligent. The conditioned soul, they commit mistake, they are illusioned, they cheat, and their senses are imperfect. This is the . . . the four condition. Therefore if we receive knowledge from the conditioned soul, there is no possibility of getting perfect knowledge. If by nature you are cheater, then how I can expect fair dealings? It is to be understood that we cannot have any fair dealings with this conditioned soul. And he’ll protest.

The whole world is full of conditioned living entities. They’re conditioned. Conditioned means under the control of the material nature. Guแน‡aiแธฅ karmฤแน‡i (BG 3.27). There are different types of conditioned souls. Some of them are good conditioned soul, some of them are passionate conditioned soul, some of them are rascal conditioned soul. So good conditioned soul means that, er, he thinks himself that, “I have become very much learned, I have studied so many books, so now I am perfect.” There is little goodness, because he has studied, he . . . he has labored, but still he’s conditioned soul, because he has imperfect vision.

Vimukta-mฤninaแธฅ. In the ลšrฤซmad-Bhฤgavatam they have been described as vimukta-mฤninaแธฅ that, “I have become now liberated, mฤninaแธฅ.” Self-complacent, thinking that “I have become now liberated. Now I have become Nฤrฤyaแน‡a, God.” These Mฤyฤvฤdฤซ sannyฤsฤซs, they address among themselves as namaแธฅ nฤrฤyaแน‡a. That means each one of them has become as good as Nฤrฤyaแน‡a, because Nฤrฤyaแน‡a is mukta. Nฤrฤyaแน‡a paraแธฅ. ลšaแน…karฤcฤrya says paraแธฅ. Paraแธฅ means liberated. Paraแธฅ and aparaแธฅ. Aparaแธฅ means conditioned. So nฤrฤyaแน‡a paraแธฅ, avyaktฤt.

Nฤrฤyaแน‡a is transcendental to this cosmic manifestation. He’s above. So the Mฤyฤvฤdฤซ philosopher, they think that, “I have become now a liberated, as good as Nฤrฤyaแน‡a, the Supreme Personality of Godhead.” But Bhฤgavatam says: “No. You are simply thinking like that. You are a rascal.” Bhฤgavatam challenges: “You are thinking that you have become now liberated, but you are a rascal.” The very . . . Bhฤgavata, Vyฤsadeva is very learned, but he says “rascal,” but in a very sweet language. (laughter) Vimukta mฤninaแธฅ.

Mฤninaแธฅ: “You are contemplating.” Why? Tvayy asta . . . ye ‘nye ‘ravindฤkแนฃa vimukta-mฤninas (SB 10.2.32). Our test is there. “I am liberated. I am Nฤrฤyaแน‡a.” Why? “How you call me rascal?” Yes, we have got a test: ye ‘nye ‘ravindฤkแนฃa vimukta-mฤninas tvayy asta-bhฤvฤd aviล›uddha-buddhayaแธฅ. Tvayy asta-bhฤvฤd. Still they have not reached the Supreme Personality of Godhead. Simply impersonal idea, and self-complacent that “I have become now Nฤrฤyaแน‡a.”

So this kind of knowledge is aviล›uddha, impure, impure knowledge, because the test is, unless one comes to the point of understanding the Personality of Godhead, the knowledge is imperfect. So they are impersonalist, and falsely thinking themselves as Nฤrฤyaแน‡a. Therefore we can immediately test that “Here is a rascal.” Vimukta-mฤninas tvayy asta-bhฤvฤd aviล›uddha-buddhayaแธฅ.

“No. We have undergone so much austerities, penances. Whole life I remain brahmacฤrฤซ, then I took sannyฤsa. I have followed the rules and regulations very strictly, and still I am rascal?” Yes, you are rascal.

(aside) Don’t make sound. Silently.

“Still I am rascal?” Yes. You are rascal. “Why?” ฤ€ruhya kแน›cchreแน‡a, “Because the symptoms are there that you are a rascal.”

So you have to understand by the symptoms. What is that symptoms? Because you left this world, “This world is false. Brahma is truth,” then why you are coming again this false world to open hospital, school, philosophy, humanitarian, all this nonsense? Why you are accepting? If it is false, and if you are in full knowledge, then why you are coming to the false platform? Therefore you are rascal. You rejected this world as false. Then why you are coming down again to the plat . . . false platform. That is rascaldom. That means your conclusion was wrong. Hmm? Your conclusion was wrong.

Just like Vivekananda and many others. Now present . . . presently there is one Karpatri. Vivekananda was actually rascal. He, he had no knowledge. But the Karpatri is actually very learned man. He has studied all the Vedas, great Sanskrit scholar, but still, because he did not worship the lotus feet of the Lord, he is also proving rascal. He is now in politics. He has got a political party, Rฤma-rฤjya Party, and nobody cares for him.

He is insulted so many place, but still, but he’s so learned, if, if anyone . . . anywhere he goes and reads scriptures and Vedas, he can give very good reference and very nicely explain, but the conclusion is dull. Conclusion is dull means again he has come to this philanthropic work. So therefore Bhฤgavata says, ฤruhya kแน›cchreแน‡a: “Although they have undergone great austerities, penances,” ฤruhya kแน›cchreแน‡a paraแน padam (SB 10.2.32), “realized to some extent the Supreme Absolute Truth,” but patanty adhaแธฅ, “falls down.”

The same example: Just like the so-called scientists, Russian and American, for so many years they’re trying to go to the moon planet, nearest planet. But there is no shelter. Actually, I do not know whether they have gone, but why they are coming back? Let them remain there, construct house there; there is everything. If there is no such possibility, why these rascals are going there?

Practically, if it is full of dust only, why these rascals are going to see the dust every time? (laughter) Ask these rascals that “What benefit? You’re spending so much money and going to the moon planet and touching, ‘Now my flag is on the dust,’ (laughter) and go back with little pebbles, ‘Oh, we have gone.’ ” No. Moon-reaching day, holiday. Nixon, another rascal, great rascalโ€”holiday.

And what do you want there? Patanty adhaแธฅ. After so much endeavor, trying to go to the moon planet, they are failing. And what to speak of other planets? What to speak of the Brahmaloka, Tapaloka, Jana . . .? They are there. We are seeing every day, at night, there are so many. Who is going there? The nearest planet, which is about 200,000 miles, I think it is so, from here, the moon planet, and they cannot go.

And what to speak of other planets? There are many. They do not . . . cannot calculate how far they are, but we see every night there. So how imperfect knowledge they are. That is my point. And still they are going as scientist. Lokasya ajฤnataแธฅ (SB 1.7.6). They are so fools and rascal, still they are passing on as scientist, big men, learned men. No. None of them. This is our challenge. None of them.

And who is learned? Learned is Vyฤsadeva. Learned is Kแน›แนฃแน‡a. So we have to take knowledge from Vyฤsadeva. Vyฤsadeva. How? Vyฤsadeva is the learned, most learned than others. How? That is explained in the Bhฤgavatam, ลšrฤซmad-Bhฤgavatam: bhakti-yogena manasi. Because he has adopted bhakti-yoga, bhakti-yogena manasi samyak praแน‡ihite amale (SB 1.7.4).

Bhakti-yogena, by practice of bhakti-yoga one’s mind and intelligence become cleansed, dirtyless, dirt . . . without any dirt. Just like the mirror, if it is without any dirt, it is cleansed, clear, you can see everything rightly, your face, or even in the spot in the face, everything, corner to corner, very nicely reflected. So bhakti-yogena, by practicing this bhakti-yoga, one becomes cleared in consciousness. That is Kแน›แนฃแน‡a consciousness. Then everything comes.

Now suppose personally, myself, we are challenging, we are calling them by names, “rascal,” but I am not a scientist. I never studied astronomy, astrology, or anything. But why I am telling? What power I have got? But I am challenging on the words of a superior answer. I am confident that the words spoken by Vyฤsadeva or Kแน›แนฃแน‡a, that is perfect. Therefore they are rascals, because their statement do not corroborate.

In other words, we can understand. That is our advantage. Bhakti-yogena. If you practice bhakti-yoga, yasya deve parฤ bhaktir yathฤ deve tathฤ gurau (ลšU 6.23), if one is . . . one has unflinching faith in the Supreme Personality of Godhead and his spiritual master, yathฤ-deve . . . deve means the Supreme Lord, and guru, and guru also, the spiritual master.

A person who has got unflinching faith in these two personalitiesโ€”guru and Kแน›แนฃแน‡aโ€”then the facility will be that all the revealed scriptures will be manifest automatically, even though he is not . . . not very learned. The purport of the whole knowledge will be revealed from within, because Kแน›แนฃแน‡a is within, and the spiritual master is without, so both of them will help.

Our students are going so many placesโ€”in the schools, colleges, universities. They’re surprised how they’re speaking so nicelyโ€”because they have got unflinching faith in Kแน›แนฃแน‡a and the spiritual master. They are not so learned. They have not gone to the college and learned so many things as the materialistic students do, but on this account: bhakti-yogena manasi.

Vyฤsadeva also did like that. He became so great because he has accepted bhakti-yoga by the order of his spiritual master, Nฤrada. Before that, he wrote so many books, Purฤแน‡as and others. He was not satisfied. When Nฤrada said that, “You cannot be satisfied by describing so many material things. You try to describe the glories of the Lord,” so after his instruction, bhakti-yogena, by practicing bhakti-yogena, manasฤซ, unto the mind, praแน‡ihite, mind became settled up, intelligence, right intelligence came, and everything became amala. Amala means without any material contamination. Then he saw apaล›yat puruแนฃaแน pลซrแน‡aแน. He saw the Supreme Personality of Godhead and also mฤyฤ. Both things he saw.

So those who are in devotional service, they have got two things: they can see what is mฤyฤ and what is Kแน›แนฃแน‡a. That is perfect life. Then he can understand how this world is going on, how Kแน›แนฃแน‡a is working. Everything becomes revealed. Bhakti-yoga is so powerful. Otherwise, what qualification we have got in comparison, their M.A., Ph.D., D.S.D. and so on, so on? Still they cannot touch the right point. Just like Dr. Stahl in Berkeley University. He talked with me, and at last he became silent. So we can challenge like that. Just like we are discussing so many philosophers.

So bhakti-yoga is so nice. So you execute bhakti-yoga very nicely, and then you become the topmost learned man in the world. This is a fact.

bhakti-yogena manasi
samyak praแน‡ihite ‘male
apaล›yat puruแนฃaแน pลซrแน‡aแน
mฤyฤแน ca tad-apฤล›rayam
(SB 1.7.4)
yayฤ sammohito jฤซva
ฤtmฤnaแน tri-guแน‡ฤtmakam
paro ‘pi manute ‘narthaแน
tat-kแน›taแน cฤbhipadyate
(SB 1.7.5)
anarthopaล›amaแน sฤkแนฃฤd
bhakti-yogam adhokแนฃaje
lokasyฤjฤnato vidvฤแนล›
cakre sฤtvata-saแนhitฤm
(SB 1.7.6)

So bhakti-yoga is so powerful. Executed properly, very simple method. Then you become the most learned man in the world. Even without going through the books, they will be revealed. Kแน›แนฃแน‡a will reveal. Kแน›แนฃแน‡a is ล›แน›แน‡vatฤแน sva-kathฤแธฅ kแน›แนฃแน‡aแธฅ puแน‡ya-ล›ravaแน‡a-kฤซrtanaแธฅ (SB 1.2.17). As you become purified by hearing the glories of the Lord, Kแน›แนฃแน‡a, puแน‡ya-ล›ra . . . hแน›dy antaแธฅ stho hy abhadrฤแน‡i, the dirty things which push obstacles and in pure understanding, they are removed. They’re washed up. Washed up.

Just like if your room is dirty, there . . . there is possibility . . . therefore I ask you, keep cleansedโ€”your bathing, your clothes, your room. Otherwise you’ll suffer hepatitis or jaundice, this, that. You’ll suffer, because you are not clean. If you clear, you remain cleansed, then there will be no disease. If you remain cleansed, you eat properlyโ€”don’t eat more, don’t eat lessโ€”there will be no disease, no doctor. That’s a fact.

But you do not know cleanliness, although you are . . . that is because your . . . your cleanliness is with machine. And without machine, you cannot keep clean. Why not this broomstick is sufficient? If in India machine is not available, you cannot be clean? Keep everything cleansedโ€”utensils, plates, teeth, hands, feet. Use sufficient water. There will be no . . . (indistinct)

Dirty things should be removed, and cleansed inside and outside. Inside cleansedโ€”simply Kแน›แนฃแน‡a consciousness, always thinking of Kแน›แนฃแน‡a. This is inside clean. And outside, that is also required. You cannot neglect, because outside unclean means inside also you’ll feel unclean. If you keep both sides clean, then you will be healthy inside and outside. ลšแน›แน‡vatฤแน sva-kathฤแธฅ kแน›แนฃแน‡a puแน‡ya-ล›ravaแน‡a-kฤซrtanaแธฅ hแน›dy antaแธฅ stho hy abhadrฤแน‡i. Abhadrฤแน‡i, all inauspicious things, that will be cleaned. They should be washed.

To become sacred thread means he must be suchi. Satya ล›amaแธฅ damaแธฅ ล›aucam. Saucham. One must be very clean. That is brahminism. Not simply having a sacred thread: “Prabhupฤda, give me sacred thread, sacred thread, sacred thread,” everybody. You have got sacred thread, that is certificate, but what is your ล›aucam? Cleanliness. The Brฤhmiแน‡’s name is suchi. He is always cleansed. Everyone will see, and he’ll immediately feel how cleansed he is.

What is the difficulty? God has given sufficient water. And for cleanliness you simply require water, that’s all. No antiseptic bottleโ€”Dettol, this, that, so many. You are manufacturing so many rascal things, but ultimately unclean. Ultimately unclean. But by God’s arrangement, by Kแน›แนฃแน‡a’s arrangement, simple . . . (break) (end)

Date: (11/12/1971)