ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป What is propositional knowledge

What is propositional knowledge

Propositional knowledge

Propositional knowledgeย orย declarative knowledgeย isย knowledgeย that someย propositionย is either true or false. This distinguishes propositional knowledge from know-how orย procedural knowledge, which is the knowledge of how to perform some task. This article discusses propositional knowledge from a variety of perspectives, includingย philosophy,ย science, andย history.

What is the difference between knowledge and beliefs? Aย beliefย is an internalย thoughtย orย memoryย which exists in one’sย mind. Most people accept that for a belief to be knowledge it must be, at least,ย trueย andย justified. Theย Gettier problemย in philosophy is the question of whether there are any other requirements before a belief can be accepted as knowledge.

The articleย Knowledge (philosophy)ย discusses the view of philosophers on how one can tell which beliefs constitute actual knowledge.

Acquiring knowledge

People have used many methods to try to gain knowledge.

  1. Byย reasonย andย logic.
  2. By mathemathicalย proof
  3. By theย scientific method.
  4. By theย trial and errorย method.
  5. By applying anย algorithm
  6. By learning fromย experience.
  7. By anย argument from authority, which could be from religious, literary, political, philosophical or scientific authorities.
  8. By listening to theย testimonyย ofย witnesses.
  9. Byย observingย the world in its “natural state”; seeing how the world operates without performing any experiments.
  10. By acquiring knowledge that is embedded in one’sย language,ย culture, orย traditions.
  11. By having aย divine illuminationย orย revelationย from a divine agency.
  12. By some claimed form of enlightenment following a period ofย meditation. (For example, the Buddhist enlightenment known asย bodhi)

Types of knowledge

Knowledge can be classified intoย a prioriย knowledge, which is obtained without needing to observe the world, and a posteriori orย empirical knowledge, which is only obtained after observing the world or interacting with it in some way. Seeย a priori and a posteriori knowledgeย for more.

Often knowledge is gained by combining or extending other knowledge in various ways.ย Isaac Newtonย famously wrote: “If I have seen further than others, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants”.

Inferential knowledge is based onย reasoningย from facts or from other inferential knowledge such as aย theory. Such knowledge may or may not beย verifiableย by observation orย testing. For example, all knowledge of theย atomย is inferential knowledge. The distinction between factual knowledge and inferential knowledge has been explored by the discipline ofย general semantics.

Knowledge in various disciplines

There are many different disciplines that generate beliefs that can be regarded as knowledge. They include science (which generates scientific theories), law (which generates verdicts), history (which generates history), and maths (which generates proofs).

Knowledge in science and engineering

Scientistsย attempt to gain knowledge through theย scientific method. In this method, scientists start by finding a phenomenon of interest, which generates questions. A scientist then picks a question of interest, and based on previous knowledge, develops a hypothesis. The scientist then designs a controlledย experimentย which will allow her to test the hypothesis against the real world. She then makes predictions about the outcome of the test, based on the hypothesis.

At this point the scientist carries out the experiment, and compares her predictions with her observations. Assuming that there were no flaws in the experiment, then if they match, then this isย evidenceย in favour of the hypothesis. If they doย notย match, then the hypothesis has beenย falsified. The next steps areย peer reviewย and publication, through which the results are distributed to other scientists.

A hypothesis that have been shown to accurately and reliably predict and characterize some physical phenomenon, and had been sufficiently peer-reviewed and tested, may become aย scientific theory. Scientific theories are widely regarded as knowledge, though they are always subject to further revision or review should new data come to light.

To use scientific theories, they must be applied to the specific situation in hand. For example, aย civil engineerย might use the theory ofย staticsย (a branch ofย physics) to determine whether or not a bridge will hold up. This is one case where new knowledge is generated from scientific knowledge byย specialisingย it to an individual instance.

Knowledge in history

The scientific method does not apply toย historyย (or related disciplines, such asย archeology), because it is not possible toย constructย experiments to test theories. Suppose a historian believes thatย Napoleonย would have won theย Battle of Waterlooย ifย Gebhard Leberecht von Blรผcherย had arrived an hour later. The historian cannot simply re-run the battle and see what would happen with different starting conditions.

Historians often generate different interpretations of the same event, even when reading the sameย primary sources, and these interpretations are always subject toย revisionย by other historians.

Situated knowledge

Knowledge gained in one situation cannot always be relied on in another situation. Imagine two very similar breeds of mushroom, which grow on either side of a mountain, one nutritious, one poisonous. Relying on knowledge from one side of an ecological boundary, after crossing to the other, may lead to starving rather than eating perfectly healthy food near at hand, or to poisoning oneself by mistake.

Some methods of generating knowledge, such asย trial and error, or learning fromย experience, tend to create highly situational knowledge. One of the main benefits of theย scientific methodย is that the theories it generates are much less situational than knowledge gained by other methods.

Situational knowledge is often embedded in language, culture, or traditions. Critics ofย cultural imperialismย argue that the rise of a globalย monocultureย causes a loss of local knowledge.

Issues

What constitutes knowledge, certainty andย truthย are controversial issues. These issues are debated byย philosophers,ย social scientists, andย historians.ย Ludwig Wittgensteinย wrote “On Certainty” –ย aphorismsย on these concepts – exploring relationships between knowledge and certainty. A thread of his concern has become an entire field, theย philosophy of action.

There are a number of problems that arise when defining knowledge or truth, including issues with objectivity, adequacy and limits to justification. Beliefs are also very problematic not least because they are either true or false, and therefore cannot be adequately described by conventionalย logic. An action likewise can be taken or not, but there is the troubling idea of an “event” is, an action taken by nobody, or nobody who you can blame.

Non-scientific methods

Some people hold that science does not actually tell us about the physical world that they live. They hold that the world cannot be understood by science, but rather by religious revelations, mystical experience, or literaryย deconstructionism.

Practical limits for obtaining knowledge

What we hold to be knowledge is often derived by a combination ofย reasonย from either traditional, authoritative, orย scientificย sources. Many times such knowledge is not verifiable; sometimes the process of testing is prohibitively dangerous or expensive. For instance, some physics theories about the nature of the universe, such as string-theory, requite the construction of testing equipment currently beyond our technology. Since such theories are in principle subject to verification or refutation, they are scientific; since they are not proven experimentally, they are not considered certain knowledge. Rather, in such cases we have certain knowledge only of the theory, but not of what the theory describes.

“Of the three ways in which men think that they acquire knowledge of thingsโ€”authority, reasoning, and experienceโ€”only the last is effective and able to bring peace to the intellect.”ย (Roger Bacon, Englishย alchemistย andย philosopher)