ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป Criminology and Criminal Law ยป DNA profiling: Statutory foundation and evidentiary significance

DNA profiling: Statutory foundation and evidentiary significance

Supreme Court of India
The recent judicial analysis in the case of Akhtar Ali versus The State of Uttarakhand highlights the statutory and evidentiary significance of DNA profiling in Indian criminal trials, particularly referencing the Nirbhaya case. The introduction of Section 53-A CrPC in 2005 allows detailed medical examinations in rape cases, recognizing DNA profiling as a vital forensic tool. The courts view DNA evidence as highly reliable, enabling the establishment of guilt or the exoneration of the innocent. While its role in modern forensic science is acknowledged, the importance of strict protocols for collection, preservation, and testing is emphasized to uphold its integrity in legal proceedings.

Ref: Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad Versus The State of Uttarakhand ([2025] 9 S.C.R. 585 : 2025 INSC 1097)

Theย statutory foundationย andย evidentiary significanceย of DNA profiling in Indian criminal trials, particularly in the context ofย Mukesh & Anr. v. State for NCT of Delhi & Ors.ย (the Nirbhaya case).

  1. Statutory Significance
    • With theย 2005 amendment to the Code of Criminal Procedure, Section 53-A CrPC was introduced.
    • This provision authorizes aย detailed medical examinationย of an accused in rape or attempted rape cases, conducted by a registered medical practitioner.
    • The explicit inclusion of DNA profiling within the statutory scheme shows legislative recognition of its importance as a forensic tool.
    • By codifying the process, the law reduces ambiguity regarding the admissibility of DNA evidence and provides procedural safeguards to ensure its reliability.
  2. Evidentiary Significance
    • DNA profiling is seen as aย highly reliable scientific techniqueย for identification.
    • Courts have noted its dual role: not only does it helpย establish guiltย by linking the accused to biological evidence found at the crime scene, but it can alsoย exonerate the innocent, thereby protecting the rights of the accused.
    • The judgment underscores that DNA profiling yieldsย conclusive resultsย compared to other forms of circumstantial or testimonial evidence, which may be more prone to error or manipulation.
    • This elevates DNA evidence to the level ofย predominant forensic evidenceย in criminal adjudication, particularly in cases involving sexual offences, homicides, or other crimes where biological material is available.
  3. Judicial Perspective
    • The Court inย Mukeshย stresses that DNA evidence is part of the โ€œmodernisationโ€ of forensic science, reflecting global standards of criminal justice.
    • The reliance on DNA evidence also demonstrates the judiciaryโ€™s recognition of science as a critical aid in theย truth-finding missionย of trials.
    • However, the judgment also implicitly points to the need forย proper collection, preservation, and testing protocols, as the reliability of DNA evidence depends heavily on the integrity of these processes.
  4. Balancing Probative Value and Fair Trial
    • While DNA evidence is powerful, courts remain conscious that it must be used with procedural safeguards. Any contamination, tampering, or improper handling of samples could compromise its value.
    • Thus, DNA evidence is not viewed in isolation but as part of theย larger evidentiary framework, corroborating or being corroborated by other forms of proof.

In essence, the Courtโ€™s observations establish DNA profiling as a statutorily sanctioned, scientifically advanced, and judicially accepted form of evidence that has transformed the administration of criminal justice in India. Its evidentiary weight lies in its capacity to provide certainty in otherwise ambiguous criminal investigations.