ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Theย Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Irelandย is the supreme legislative institution in theย United Kingdomย andย British overseas territoriesย (it alone hasย parliamentary sovereignty). At its head is theย Sovereign; it also includes an Upper House, called theย House of Lords, and a Lower House, called theย House of Commons. The House of Lords includes two different types of membersโ€”the Lords Spiritual (the seniorย clergyย of theย Church of England) and the Lords Temporal (members of theย Peerage); it is an almost wholly appointed body. The House of Commons, on the other hand, is a democratically elected chamber. The House of Lords and the House of Commons meet in seperate chambers in theย Palace of Westminster, in the United Kingdom’s capitalย London, which is commonly known as the “Houses of Parliament.”

Parliament evolved from the ancient council which advised the Sovereign. In theory, power is vested not in Parliament, but in the “Queen-in-Parliament” (or “King-in-Parliament”). The Queen-in-Parliament is often said to be a completely sovereign authority, though such a position is debatable. In modern times, real power is vested in the democratically elected House of Commons; the Sovereign acts only as a figurehead, and the powers of the House of Lords are greatly limited.

The British Parliament is often called the “Mother of Parliaments,” as the legislative bodies of many nationsโ€”most notably, those of the members of theย Commonwealthโ€”are modeled on it. However, it is a misquotation ofย John Bright, who had actually remarked onย 18 Januaryย 1865ย that “England is the Mother of Parliaments”, in the context of supporting demands for expanded voting rights in a country which had pioneered Parliamentary government.

History

One may trace the origin of Parliament to the times of theย Anglo-Saxons. Anglo-Saxon Kings were advised by a council known as theย Witenagemot, whose foremost members were the King’s sons and brothers. The Earldormen, or executive heads of theย shires, also had seats in the Witenagemot, as did the senior clergymen of the state. The King still possessed ultimate authority, but laws were made only after seeking the advice (and, in later times, the consent) of the Witenagemot.

The entire Anglo-Saxon body politic was reformed whenย William of Normandyย conquered England inย 1066. William brought toย Englandย theย feudal systemย he was accustomed to in his nativeย France. Thus, he granted land to his most important military supporters, who in turn granted land to their supporters, thus creating a feudal hierarchy. Those who held lands directly from the King were known as tenants-in-chief, and the territories they held were calledย manors. William I was an absolute ruler, but, as a matter of course, he sought the advice of a council of tenants-in-chief and ecclesiastics, before making laws.

The tenants-in-chief often struggled with their spiritual counterparts and with the King for power. Inย 1215, they secured fromย Johnย theย Magna Carta, which established that the King may not levy or collect any taxes (except the feudal taxes to which they were hitherto accustomed), save with the consent of his council. It was also established that the most important tenants-in-chief (theย earlsย and theย barons), as well as the ecclesiastics (archbishops,ย bishopsย andย abbots) be summoned to the council by personal writs from the Sovereign, and that all others be summoned to the council by general writs from theย sheriffsย of their counties. John later repealed the Magna Carta, butย Henry IIIย reinstated it.

The royal council slowly developed into a Parliament. Inย 1265,ย Simon de Montfort, 6th Earl of Leicester, who was in rebellion againstย King Edward I, summoned a parliament of his supporters without any or prior royal authorisation. The archbishops, bishops, abbots, earls and barons were summoned, as were twoย knightsย from each shire and two burgesses from eachย borough. Knights had been summoned to previous councils, but the representation of the boroughs was unprecedented. De Montfort’s scheme was formally adopted byย Edward Iย in the so-called “Model Parliament” ofย 1295. At first, eachย estateย debated independently; by the reign ofย Edward III, however, Parliament had been separated into two Houses: one, including the nobility and higher clergy, the other, including the knights and burgesses. The authority of Parliament grew under Edward III; it was established that no law could be made, nor any tax levied, without the consent of both Houses as well as of the Sovereign.

The growing influence of Parliament was restrained by numerousย civil wars. By the end of theย Wars of the Roses, royal supremacy had been restored. The Crown was at the height of its power during the reign ofย Henry VIII. The number of theย Lords Spiritualย diminished under Henry, who commanded theย Dissolution of the Monasteries, thereby depriving the abbots and priors of their seats in the Upper House. For the first time, the Lords Temporal were more numerous than the Lords Spiritual.

Parliaments continued to behave submissively under theย Tudorย monarchs who followed Henry, but began to display an unusual sense of independence underย Elizabeth I. As England evolved into a world power, members of both Houses actively discussed succession to the Crown (the Queen never married) and condemned various royal policies. Their new-found boldness proved intolerable to Elizabeth’sย Scottishย successor,ย James Iย (who was simultaneously King in Scotland as James VI). The great struggle between the Crown and Parliament occurred under James I’s successor,ย Charles I. Alarmed by the arbitrary exercise of royal power, the House of Commons submitted to Charles theย Petition of Right, demanding the restoration of their liberties, inย 1628. Though he accepted the petition, he later dissolved Parliament and ruled without them for eleven years. It was only after the financial disaster of the Scottishย Bishops’ Warsย (1639โ€“1640) that he was forced to recall Parliament in order that they may authorise new taxes. The new Parliament was quite rebellious; their struggle for power with the Crown culminated in theย English Civil War. Inย 1649, Charles was executed and replaced by the military dictatorย Oliver Cromwell. The House of Lords was abolished, and the House of Commons remained subordinate to Cromwell. After Cromwell’s death, however, the monarchy was restored inย 1660. The House of Lords also returned.

Followingย the Restoration, monarchs undertook to regularly summon Parliament. Nevertheless, there was no explicit guarantee of Parliamentary liberties untilย James II, an unpopular Catholic ruler, was forced to flee the country inย 1688. Parliament “deemed” that he had abdicated, but it offered the Crown to his Protestant daughterย Mary, instead of his Catholic son. Mary II ruled jointly with her husband,ย William III. They agreed to theย Act Declaring the Rights and Liberties of the Subject and Settling the Succession of the Crownย (the Bill of Rights), which acknowledged several powers Parliaments had claimed under previous Stuart monarchs. No taxes were to be levied, nor any standing armies to be kept during peacetime, without the consent of Parliament. Freedom of speech in Parliamentary debates was also secured.

The influence of Parliament was undoubtedly augmented by the Bill of Rights, but the supremacy of the Crown stil remained clear. It was only after theย Hanoverianย George Iย ascended the Throne inย 1714ย that power began to shift from the Sovereign. George was aย Germanย ruler, spoke poor English and preferred to concentrate on his dominions inย Europe. He thus entrusted power to a group of his ministers, the foremost of which wasย Sir Robert Walpole.ย George IIIย sought to restore royal supremacy, but by the end of his reign, the position of the ministersโ€”who would in turn have to rely on Parliament for supportโ€”was cemented.

The principle of ministerial responsibility to the Lower House did not develop until theย nineteenth century. The House of Lords was superior to the House of Commons both in theory and in practice. Members of the House of Commons were elected in an antiquatedย electoral system, under whichย constituenciesย of vastly different sizes existed. Thus, the borough ofย Old Sarum, with seven voters, could elect two members, as could the borough ofย Dunwich, which had completely disappeared into the sea due to land erosion. In many cases, members of the Upper House controlled tiny constituencies, known as pocket boroughs orย rotten boroughs, and could ensure the election of their relatives or supporters. Many seats in the House of Commons were “owned” by the Lords. After the reforms of the nineteenth century (beginning inย 1832), the electoral system in the Lower House was much more regularised. No longer dependent on the Upper House for their seats, members of the House of Commons began to grow more assertive.

The supremacy of the House of Commons was clearly established during the earlyย twentieth century. Inย 1909, the Commons passed the so-called “People’s Budget,” which made numerous changes to the taxation stystem in a manner detrimental to wealthy landowners. The House of Lords, which mostly consisted of powerful landowning aristocrats, rejected the Budget. On the basis of the Budget’s popularity and the Lords’ consequent unpopularity, theย Liberal Partyย won aย general electionย inย 1910. Using the result as a mandate, the Liberalย Prime Minister,ย Herbert Henry Asquith, introduced the Parliament Bill, which sought to restrict the powers of the House of Lords. (He did not reintroduce the land tax provision of the People’s Budget.) When the Lords refused to pass the bill, Asquith approached the King and requested the creation of several hundred Liberal peers so as to erase theย Conservativeย majority in the House of Lords. In the face of such a threat, the House of Lords reluctantly passed the bill. Theย Parliament Act 1911, as it became known, allowed the Lords to delay a bill for a maximum of three sessions (reduced to two sessions inย 1949), after which it could become law over their objections.

Further reforms to the House of Lords have been made during the twentieth century. Inย 1958, the Life Peerages Act authorised the regular creation ofย life peerageย dignities. By theย 1960s, the regular creation of hereditary peerage dignities had ceased; thereafter, almost all new peers were life peers only. More recently, theย House of Lords Act 1999ย has removed the automatic right of hereditary peers to sit in the Upper House (although it made an exception for ninety-two of them on a temporary basis). The House of Lords is now a chamber that is, in practice, subordinate to the House of Commons.

Composition

At the head of Parliament is the British Sovereign. The Sovereign’s role, however, is merely ceremonial; in practice, he or she always acts on the advice of theย Prime Ministerย and other ministers, who are in turn accountable to the two Houses of Parliament.

The Upper House, the House of Lords, is mostly made up of appointed members (“Lords of Parliament”). The whole House is formally styledย The Right Honourable The Lords Spiritual and Temporal in Parliament Assembled, the Lords Spiritual being clergymen of theย Church of Englandย and the Lords Temporal beingย Peers of the Realm. The Lords Spiritual and Lords Temporal are considered separate “estates,” but they sit, debate and vote together.

The Lords Spiritual formerly included all of the senior clergymen of the Church of Englandโ€”archbishops, bishops, abbots and priors. Upon the Dissolution of the Monasteries under Henry VIII, however, the abbots and priors lost their positions in Parliament. All diocesan bishops continued to sit in Parliament, but the Bishopric of Manchester Act 1847 and later acts provide that only the twenty-six most senior are Lords Spiritual. These twenty-six always include the incumbents of the “five greatย sees,” namely, theย Archbishop of Canterbury, theย Archbishop of York, theย Bishop of London, theย Bishop of Durhamย and theย Bishop of Winchester. The remaining twenty-one Lords Spiritual are the most senior diocesan bishops, ranked in order ofย consecration.

The Lords Temporal are all members of theย Peerage. Formerly, they included hereditary peers, of the ranks of Duke, Marquess, Earl, Viscount and Baron. The right of some hereditary peers to sit in Parliament was not automatic: after Scotland and England united into Great Britain in 1707, it was provided that all peers whose dignities had been created by English Kings could sit in Parliament, but those whose dignities had been created by Scottish Kings were to elect a limited number of “representative peers.” A similar arrangement was made in respect of Ireland when that nation merged with Great Britain in 1801. But when Southern Ireland left the United Kingdom in 1922, the election of Irish representative peers ceased. By theย Peerage Act 1963, the election of Scottish representative peers also ended, but all Scottish peers were granted the right to sit in Parliament. Under the House of Lords Act 1999, only life peerage dignities (that is to say, peerage dignities which cannot be inherited) automatically entitle their holders to seats in the House of Lords. Of the hereditary peers, only ninety-twoโ€”the individuals exercising the offices ofย Earl Marshalย andย Lord Great Chamberlain, in addition to ninety hereditary peers elected by other peersโ€”retain their seats in the House.

The Commons, the last of the “estates” of the Kingdom, are represented in the House of Commons, which is formally styledย The Honourable The Commons in Parliament Assembled. The House consists of 659 members (“Members of Parliament” or “MPs”), each of whom is chosen by a single constituency according to theย First-Past-the-Postย electoral system. Universal adultย suffrageย prevails; citizens of the United Kingdom, as well as citizens of theย Republic of Irelandย and ofย Commonwealth nationsย resident in the United Kingdom, are qualified to vote. The term of members of the House of Commons depends on the term of Parliament; aย general election, during which all the seats are contested, occurs after each dissolution (see below).

The three branches of Parliament are supposed to be kept separate from each other; no individual may form a part of more than one component of Parliament. Lords of Parliament are legally barred from voting in elections for members of the House of Commons; furthermore, the Sovereign by convention does not vote, although there is no statutory impediment.

Procedure

Each of the two Houses of Parliament is presided over by a Speaker. In the House of Lords, theย Lord Chancellor, a member of the Cabinet, is theย ex officioย Speaker. Where there is a vacancy in the office, a Speaker may be appointed by the Crown. Deputy Speakers, who take the place of an absent Lord Chancellor, are also chosen by the Crown.

The House of Commons has the right to elect its ownย Speakerย Theoretically, the approval of the Sovereign is required before the election becomes valid, but it is, by modern conventions, always granted. The Speaker’s place may be taken by three deputies, known as the Chairman, First Deputy Chairman and Second Deputy Chairman of Ways and Means. (They take their name from the Committee of Ways and Means, of which they were once presiding officers, but which no longer exists.)

In general, the Lord Chancellor’s influence as Speaker is very limited, whilst the powers belonging to the Speaker of the House of Commons are vast. Decisions on points of order and on the disciplining of unruly members are made by the whole body in the Upper House, but by the Speaker alone in the Lower House. Speeches in the House of Lords are addressed to the House as a whole (using the words “My Lords”), but those in the House of Commons are addressed to the Speaker alone (using the words “Mr Speaker” or “Madam Speaker”).

Both Houses may decide questions with voice voting; members shout out “Aye” and “No” (in the House of Commons), or “Content” and “Not-Content” (in the House of Lords), and the presiding officer declares the result. The pronouncement of the Lord Chancellor or Speaker may be challenged, and a recorded vote (known as aย division) demanded. (The Speaker of the House of Commons may choose to overrule a frivolous request for a division, but the Lord Chancellor does not possess an equivalent power.) In each House, a division requires members to file into one of the two lobbies alongside the Chamber; their names are recorded by clerks, and their votes are counted as they exit the lobbies to re-enter the Chamber. The Speaker of the House of Commons, who is expected to remain non-partisan, does not cast a vote except in the case of a tie; the Lord Chancellor, however, votes along with the other Lords.

Term

Following a general election, a new Parliamentary session begins. Parliament is formally summoned forty days in advance by the Sovereign, who is considered the source of parliamentary authority. On the day indicated by the Sovereign’s proclamation, the two Houses assemble in their respective chambers. The Commons are then summoned to the House of Lords, whereย Lords Commissionersย (representatives of the Sovereign) instruct them to elect a Speaker. The Commons perform the election; on the next day, they return to the House of Lords, where the Lords Commissioners confirm the election and grant the new Speaker the royal approval in the Sovereign’s name.

The business of Parliament for the next few days of its session involves the taking of the oaths of allegiance. Once a majority of the members have taken the oath in each House, the State Opening of Parliament may occur. The Lords take their seats in the House of Lords Chamber, the Commons appear at the Bar (immediately outside the Chamber), and the Sovereign takes his or her seat on a throne. The Sovereign then reads theย Speech from the Throneโ€”the content of which is determined by the Ministers of the Crownโ€”outlining the Government’s legislative agenda for the upcoming year. Thereafter, each House proceeds to the transaction of legislative business.

By custom, before considering the Government’s legislative agenda, a bill is introducedย pro formaย in each Houseโ€”the Select Vestries Bill in the House of Lords and theย Outlawries Billย in the House of Commons. These bills do not actually become laws; they are merely ceremonial indications of the power of each House to debate independently of the Crown. After theย pro formaย bill is introduced, each House debates the content of the Speech from the Throne for several days. Once each House formally sends its reply to the Speech, the proper legislative business of the House may commence. At once, each House becomes fully active in appointing committees, electing officers, passing resolutions and considering legislation.

A session of Parliament is brought to an end by a prorogation. There is a ceremony similar to the State Opening, but it is much less well-known. Normally, the Sovereign does not personally attend the prorogation ceremony in the House of Lords; rather, he or she is represented by Lords Commissioners. The next session of Parliament begins under the procedures described above, but it is not necessary to conduct another election of a Speaker or take the oaths of allegiance afresh at the beginning of such subsequent sessions. Instead, the State Opening of Parliament is proceeded to directly.

Each Parliament, after a number of sessions, comes to an end, either by the command of the Sovereign or by effluxion of time, the former being more common in modern times. The dissolution of Parliament is effected by the Sovereign, but always on the advice of the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister may seek a dissolution because the time is politically advantageous to his or her party. Furthermore, if the Prime Minister loses the support of the House of Commons, he must either resign or seek a dissolution of Parliament to renew his or her mandate.

Originally, there was no fixed limit on the length of a Parliament, but the Triennial Act 1694 set the maximum duration at three years. As the frequent elections were deemed inconvenient, the Septennial Act 1716 extended the maximum duration to seven years, but theย Parliament Act 1911ย reduced it to five years. During theย Second World War, the term was temporarily extended to ten years by Acts of Parliament. Since the end of the war inย 1945, however, the maximum term has remained five years. Modern Parliaments, however, rarely continue for the maximum duration; normally, they are dissolved earlier. For instance, the Fifty-Second Parliament assembled inย 1997, but was dissolved after only four years.

Formerly, the demise of the Sovereign automatically brought a Parliament to an end, for the Crown was seen as theย caput, principium, et finisย (beginning, basis and end) of the body. It was, however, deemed inconvenient to have no Parliament at a time when succession to the Crown could be disputed. Thus, a statute passed during the reign of William III and Mary II provided that a Parliament was to continue for six months after the death of a Sovereign, unless dissolved earlier. The Representation of the People Act 1867 brought this arrangement to an end; now, a demise in the Crown does not affect the duration of a Parliament.

After each Parliament concludes, a general election is held, and new members of the House of Commons elected. The membership of the House of Lords, however, does not change due to a dissolution. Each Parliament which assembles following a general election is deemed to be distinct from the one which just concluded. Thus, each Parliament is separately numbered, the present Parliament being the Fifty-Third Parliament of the United Kingdom (that is to say, the fifty-third Parliament summoned since the formation of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland inย 1801). Previous Parliaments were “of Great Britain” or “of England.”

Legislative functions

Laws, in draft form known as bills, may be introduced by any member of either House. Usually, however, a bill is introduced by a Minister of the Crown. A bill introduced by a Minister is known as a “Government Bill”; one introduced by another member is called a “Private Member’s Bill.” A different way of categorising bills involves the subject. Most bills, involving the general public, are called “Public Bills.” A bill that seeks to grant special rights to an individual or small group of individuals is called a “Private Bill.” A Private Bill which has broader public implications is called a “Hybrid Bill.”

Each Bill goes through several stages in each House. The first stage, called theย first reading, is a mere formality. At the next stage, theย second reading, the general principles of the bill are debated. At the second reading, the House may vote to reject the bill (by refusing to pass the motion “That the Bill be now read a second time”), but defeats of Government Bills are extremely rare.

Following the second reading, the bill is sent to a committee. In the House of Lords, the Committee of the Whole House or the Grand Committee is used. Each consists of all members of the House; the latter operates under special procedures, and is used only for uncontroversial bills. In the House of Commons, the bill is usually committed to a Standing Committee, consisting of between sixteen and fifty members, but the Committee of the Whole House is used for important legislation. Several other types of committees, including Select Committes, may be used, but are in practice only rarely employed. A committee considers the bill clause-by-clause, and reports its proposed amendments to the entire House, where further detailed consideration occurs.

Once the House considers the bill, the third reading follows. In the House of Commons, no further amendments may be made, and the passage of the motion “That the Bill be now read a third time” amounts to passage of the whole bill. In the House of Lords, however, further amendments to the bill may be moved. After the passage of the third reading motion mentioned above, the House of Lords must vote on another motion “That the Bill do now pass.” Following its passage in one House, the bill is sent to the other House. If passed in identical form by both Houses, it may be presented for the Sovereign’s Assent. If, however, one House passes amendments that the other will not agree to, and the two Houses cannot resolve their disagreements, the bill fails.

Since the passage of the Parliament Act 1911, however, the power of the House of Lords to interfere with bills passed by the House of Commons has been restricted. Further restrictions were placed by the Parliament Act 1949. Thus, if the House of Commons passes a public bill in two successive sessions, and the House of Lords rejects them both times, then the Commons may direct that the bill be presented to the Sovereign for his or her Assent, disregarding the rejection of the Bill in the House of Lords. In each case, the bill must be passed by the House of Commons at least one calendar month before the end of the session. The provision does not apply to bills originated in the House of Lords, to bills seeking to extend the duration of a Parliament beyond five years or to Private Bills. A special procedure applies in relation to bills classified by the Speaker of the House of Commons as “Money Bills.” A Money Billย solelyย concerns national taxation or public funds; the Speaker’s certificate is deemed conclusive under all circumstances. If the House of Lords fails to pass a Money Bill within one month of its passage in the House of Commons, the Lower House may direct that the Bill be submitted for the Sovereign’s Assent immediately.

Even before the passage of the Parliament Acts, the Commons possessed pre-eminence in cases of financial matters. By ancient custom, the House of Lords may neither introduce a bill relating to taxation orย Supply, nor amend a bill so as to insert a provision relating to taxation or Supply, nor amend a Supply Bill in any way. The House of Commons, however, is free to waive this privilege, and sometimes does so to allow the House of Lords to pass amendments with financial implications. The House of Lords, however, remains free to reject bills relating to Supply and taxation, but may be easily overruled if the bills are Money Bills. (A bill relating to revenue and Supply may not be a Money Bill if, for example, it includes subjects other than national taxation and public funds).

The last stage of a bill involves the granting of theย Royal Assent. Theoretically, the Sovereign may grant the Royal Assent (that is, make the bill a law) or withhold the Royal Assent (that is, veto the bill). Under modern notions of a constitutional monarchy, however, the Sovereign always grants the Royal Assent. The last refusal to grant the Assent came inย 1708, whenย Anneย withheld her Assent from a bill “for the settling of Militia in Scotland.”

Every bill, thus, obtains the assent of all three components of Parliament before it becomes law (except as provided by theย Parliament Actsย where the House of Lords is overriden). All laws are in theory “enacted” by the Sovereign, with the consent of the Lords and Commons. The words “BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s [King’s] most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-” form a part of each Act of Parliament (where the House of Lords’ authority has been overriden through the usage of the Parliament Acts, the words “BE IT ENACTED by The Queen’s [King’s] most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Commons in this present Parliament assembled, in accordance with the provisions of the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-” are used instead). These words at the beginning of every Act is known as the enacting formula.

Judicial functions

In addition to its legislative functions, Parliament also performs several judicial functions. The Queen-in-Parliament constitutes the highest court in the realm for most purposes, but theย Privy Councilย has jurisdiction in some cases (for instance, appeals from ecclesiastical courts). The jurisdiction of Parliament arises from the ancient custom of petitioning the Houses to redress grievances and to do justice. The House of Commons ceased considering petitions to reverse the judgements of lower courts inย 1399, effectively leaving the House of Lords as the realm’s court of last resort. In modern times, theย judicial functions of the House of Lordsย are performed not by the whole House, but by a group of “Lords of Appeal in Ordinary” (judges granted life peerage dignities under the Appellate Jurisdiction Act 1876 by the Sovereign) and by “Lords of Appeal” (other peers with experience in the judiciary). The Lords of Appeal in Ordinary and Lords of Appeal (or “Law Lords”) are Lords of Parliament, but normally do not vote or speak on political matters.

Certain other judicial functions have historically been performed by the House of Lords. Untilย 1948, it was the body in which peers of the Realm had to be tried for felonies orย high treason; now, peers are tried by normal juries. Furthermore, when the House of Commonsย impeachesย an individual, the trial takes place in the House of Lords. Impeachments, however, are now obsolete; the last impeachment occurred inย 1806.

Relationship with the Government

The British Government is answerable to the House of Commons. However, neither the Prime Minister nor members of the Government are elected by the House of Commons. Instead, the Queen requests the person most likely to command the support of a majority in the House, normally the leader of the largest party in the House of Commons, to form a government. So that they may be accountable to the Lower House, the Prime Minister and most members of the Cabinet are members of the House of Commons instead of the House of Lords. The last Prime Minister to be a Lord of Parliament wasย Alec Douglas-Home, 14th Earl of Home, who became Prime Minister inย 1963. Nevertheless, to adhere to the convention under which he was responsible to the Lower House, Lord Home disclaimed his peerage dignity and procured election to the House of Commons.

Parliament controls the executive by passing or rejecting its Bills and by forcing Ministers of the Crown to answer for their actions, either at “Question Time” or during meetings of theย parliamentary committees. In both cases, the Ministers are asked questions by members of their Houses, and are obliged to answer.

Although the House of Lords may scrutinise the executive through Question Time and through its committees, it cannot bring about the end of a Government. A ministry must, however, always retain the confidence and support of the House of Commons. The Lower House may indicate its lack of support by rejecting aย Motion of Confidenceย or by passing aย Motion of No Confidence. Confidence Motions are generally originated by the Government in order to reinforce its support in the House, whilst No Confidence Motions are introduced by the Opposition. The motions sometimes take the form “That this House has [no] confidence in Her Majesty’s Government” but several other varieties, many referring to specific policies supported or opposed by Parliament, are often used. For instance, a Confidence Motion ofย 1992ย used the form, “That this House expresses the support for the economic policy of Her Majesty’s Government.” Such a motion may theoretically be introduced in the House of Lords, but, as the Government need not enjoy the confidence of that House, would not be of the same effect as a similar motion in the House of Commons; the only modern instance of such an occurrence involves the No Confidence Motion that was introduced inย 1993, and subsequently defeated.

Many votes are considered votes of confidence, although not specifically involving the language mentioned above. Important bills that form part of the Government’s agenda (as stated in the Speech from the Throne) are generally considered matters of confidence. The defeat of such a bill by the House of Commons indicates that a Government no longer has the confidence of that House. Furthermore, the same effect is achieved if the House of Commons “withdraws Supply,” that is, rejects the Budget.

Where a Government has lost the confidence of the House of Commons, the Prime Minister is obliged to either resign, or seek the dissolution of Parliament and a new general election. Where a Prime Minister has ceased to retain a majority in that vote and requests a dissolution, the Sovereign can in theory reject his request, forcing his resignation and allowing theย Leader of the Oppositionย to be asked to form a new government. This power however is supposed to be used extremely rarely. The conditions that should be met to allow such a refusal are known as theย Lascelles Principles. Note, however, that these conditions and principles are merely informal conventions; it is possible, though highly improbable, for the Sovereign to refuse a dissolution for no reason at all.

In practice, the House of Commons’ scrutiny of the Government is very weak. Since the First-Past-the-Post electoral system is employed in elections, the governing party tends to enjoy a large majority in the Commons; there is often limited need to compromise with other parties. Modern British political parties are so tightly organised that they leave relatively little room for free action by their MPs. In many cases, MPs may be expelled from their parties for voting against the instructions of party leaders. During the twentieth century, the Government has lost confidence issues only thriceโ€”twice inย 1924, and once inย 1979.

Sovereignty

Several different views have been taken of Parliament’s sovereignty. According to the juristย Sir William Blackstone, “It has sovereign and uncontrollable authority in making, confirming, enlarging, restraining, abrogating, repealing, reviving, and expounding of laws, concerning matters of all possible denominations, ecclesiastical, or temporal, civil, military, maritime, or criminal โ€ฆ It can, in short, do every thing that is not naturally impossible.”

A different view, however, has been taken by the Scottish judge Lord Cooper of Culross. When he decided the case ofย MacCormick v. Lord Advocateย asย Lord President of the Court of Session, he stated, “the principle of unlimited sovereignty of Parliament is a distinctively English principle and has no counterpart in Scottish constitutional law.” He continued, “Considering that theย Union legislationย extinguished the Parliaments of Scotland and England and replaced them by a new Parliament, I have difficulty in seeing why the new Parliament of Great Britain must inherit all the peculiar characteristics of the English Parliament but none of the Scottish.” Nevertheless, he did not give a conclusive opinion on the subject. Thus, the question of Parliamentary sovereignty appears to remain unresolved. Parliament has not passed any Act defining its own sovereignty.

Parliament’s power has often been eroded by its own Acts. Acts passed inย 1921ย andย 1925ย grant the Church of Scotland complete independence in ecclesiastical matters. More recently, its power has been restricted by the United Kingdom’s membership of theย European Union, which has the power to make laws enforceable in each member state. In theย Factortame case, theย European Court of Justiceย ruled that UK courts could have powers to overturn legislation contravening EU law. This new power is a breach ofย parliamentary sovereignty, which is part of theย UK constitution. Parliament has also created national devolved assemblies with legislative authority inย Scotland,ย Walesย andย Northern Ireland. Similarly, it has granted the power to make regulations to Ministers of the Crown, and the power to enact religious legislation to theย General Synodย of the Church of England. (Measures of the General Synod and, in some cases, proposed statutory instruments made by ministers must be approved by both Houses before they become law.) In every case aforementioned, however, authority has been conceded by Act of Parliament, and may be taken back in the same manner. It is entirely within the authority of Parliament to, for example, abolish the devolved governments in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland or to leave the EU. However, especially in the case of withdrawing from EU membership, the political costs (the UK’s economy and reputation in Europe would most likely be hugely damaged) of such a move would surely prevent it from occurring. Although legally Parliament’s sovereignty has not been curtailed, in a politically sense it sovereignty has been reduced by Parliament’s own Acts, especially theย European Communities Act 1972 (UK), which made the UK a member of the EU.

One well-recognised exception to Parliament’s power involves binding future Parliaments. No Act of Parliament may be made secure from amendment or repeal by a future Parliament. For example, although theย Act of Union 1800ย states that the Kingdoms of Great Britain and Ireland are to be united “forever,” Parliament permitted Southern Ireland to separate into a distinct nation, theย Irish Free State, inย 1922.

Privileges

Each House of Parliament possesses and guards various ancient privileges. The House of Lords rely on inherent right. In the case of the House of Commons, the Speaker goes to the Lords’ Chamber at the beginning of each new Parliament and requests representatives of the Sovereign to confirm the Lower House’s “undoubted” privileges and rights. The ceremony observed by the House of Commons dates to the reign of Henry VIII. Each House is the guardian of its privileges, and may punish breaches thereof. The extent of parliamentary privilege is based on law and custom. Sir William Blackstone states that these privileges are “very large and indefinite,” and cannot be defined except by the Houses of Parliament themselves.

The foremost privilege claimed by both Houses is that ofย freedom of speechย in debate; nothing said in either House may be questioned in any court or other institution outside Parliament. Another privilege is that of freedom fromย arrestย except forย high treason,ย felonyย orย breach of the peace; it applies from during a session of Parliament, as well as forty days before or after such a session. Members of both Houses are also privileged from service onย juries.

Both Houses possess the power to punish breaches of their privilege. Contempt of Parliament โ€” for example, disobedience of aย subpoenaย issued by a committee โ€” may also be punished. The House of Lords may imprison an individual for any fixed period of time, but an individual imprisoned by the House of Commons is set free upon prorogation. The punishments imposed by either House may not be challenged in any court.