ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป What is a judgment

What is a judgment

Aย judgmentย orย judgement, in aย legalย context, is synonymous with the formal decision made by aย courtย followingย legal proceedings. At the same time the court may also make a range ofย court orders, such as imposing aย sentenceย upon aย guiltyย defendantย in aย criminalย matter, or providing aย remedyย for theย plaintiffย in aย civilย matter.

In theย United States, under the rules ofย civil procedureย governing practice in federal courts and most state courts, theย entry of judgmentย is the final order entered by the court in the case, leaving no further action to be taken by the court with respect to the issues contested by the parties to the lawsuit. With certain exceptions, only aย final judgmentย is subject toย appeal.

In other contexts, a judgment implies a balanced weighing up of evidence preparatory to making a decision. A formal process of evaluation applies. A judgment may be expressed as a statement, e.g. S1: ‘A is B’ and is usually the outcome of an evaluation of alternatives. The formal process of evaluation can sometimes be described as a set of conditions and criteria that must be satisfied in order for a judgment to be made. What follows is a suggestive list of some conditions that are commonly required:

  • there must beย corroborating evidenceย for S1,
  • there must be no true contradicting statements,
  • if there are contradicting statements, these must be outweighed by the corroborating evidence for S1, or
  • contradicting statements must themselves have no corroborating evidence
  • S1 must also corroborate and be corroborated by the system of statements which are accepted as true.

One should be cautious in attributing, without rigorous analysis, a rigid set of criteria to all forms of judgment. Often this results in unnecessary restrictions to judgment methodologies, excluding what may otherwise be considered legitimate judgments. For analogous difficulties in science and the scientific method see the Wikipedia entry on the scientific method.

From the criteria mentioned above, we could judge that “It is raining” if there are raindrops hitting the window, if people outside are using umbrellas, and if there are clouds in the sky. Someone who says that despite all this, it is not raining, but cannot provide evidence for this, would not undermine our judgment.

However, if they demonstrated that there were a sophisticated projection and audio system to produce the illusion of our evidence, then we would probably reconsider our judgment. However, we would not do this lightly, we would demand evidence of the existence of such a system. Then it would need to be decided again upon available new evidence whether or not it was raining.

Many forms of judgment, including the above example, require that they be supported by, and support, known facts which are themselves well supported, and its negation must be shown to be unfounded before it is accepted as well-founded.