Section 89 starts with the words โwhere it appears to the court that there exist elements ofย a settlementโ. This clearly shows that cases which are not suited for ADR process should notย be referred under section 89 of the Code. The court has to form an opinion that a case is oneย that is capable of being referred to and settled through ADR process. Having regard to theย tenor of the provisions of Rule 1A of Order 10 of the Code, the civil court should invariablyย refer cases to ADR process. Only in certain recognized excluded categories of cases, it mayย choose not to refer to an ADR process. Where the case is unsuited for reference to any ofย the ADR process, the court will have to briefly record the reasons for not resorting to anyย of the settlement procedures prescribed under section 89 of the Code. Therefore, having aย hearing after completion of pleadings, to consider recourse to ADR process under sectionย 89 of the Code, is mandatory. But actual reference to an ADR process in all cases is notย mandatory. Where the case falls under an excluded category there need not be reference toย ADR process. In all other case reference to ADR process is a must.
The following categories of cases are normally considered to be not suitable for ADR processย having regard to their nature :
(i) Representative suits under Order 1 Rule 8 CPC which involve public interest or interestย of numerous persons who are not parties before the court. (In fact, even a compromiseย in such a suit is a difficult process requiring notice to the persons interested in theย suit, before its acceptance).
(ii) Disputes relating to election to public offices (as contrasted from disputes betweenย two groups trying to get control over the management of societies, clubs, associationย etc.).
(iii) Cases involving grant of authority by the court after enquiry, as for example, suits for
grant of probate or letters of administration.
(iv) Cases involving serious and specific allegations of fraud, fabrication of documents,ย forgery, impersonation, coercion etc.
(v) Cases requiring protection of courts, as for example, claims against minors, deitiesย and mentally challenged and suits for declaration of title against government.
(vi) Cases involving prosecution for criminal offences.
All other suits and cases of civil nature in particular the following categories of casesย (whether pending in civil courts or other special Tribunals/Forums) are normally suitableย for ADR processes :
(i) All cases relating to trade, commerce and contracts, including
โข disputes arising out of contracts (including all money claims);
โข disputes relating to specific performance;
โข disputes between suppliers and customers;
โข disputes between bankers and customers;
โข disputes between developers/builders and customers;
โข disputes between landlords and tenants/licensor and licensees;(2008) 2 SCC 660
28
โข disputes between insurer and insured;
(ii) All cases arising from strained or soured relationships, including
โข disputes relating to matrimonial causes, maintenance, custody of children;
โข disputes relating to partition/division among family members/co- parceners/
co-owners; and
โข disputes relating to partnership among partners.
(iii) All cases where there is a need for continuation of the pre-existing relationship in
spite of the disputes, including
โข disputes between neighbours (relating to easementary rights, encroachments,
nuisance etc.);
โข disputes between employers and employees;
โข disputes among members of societies/associations/Apartment owners
Associations;
(iv) All cases relating to tortious liability including
โข claims for compensation in motor accidents/other accidents; and
(v) All consumer disputes including
โข disputes where a trader/supplier/manufacturer/service provider is keen to
maintain his business/professional reputation and credibility or `product
popularity.
The above enumeration of `suitableโ and `unsuitableโ categorization of cases is not intendedย to be exhaustive or rigid. They are illustrative, which can be subjected to just exceptions orย additions by the court/Tribunal exercising its jurisdiction/discretion in referring a dispute/ย case to an ADR process. [ย AFCONs Infrastructure Ltd. and AnOTHER Vs Cherian Varkey Construction Co. (P) Ltd. and OTHERS [ALL SC 2010 JULY ]


More Stories
Title 2 โ The Congress (U.S. State Code): Congress, Elections, Committees, Budget and Congressional Administration
1 U.S. Code Sec 1 – Words denoting number, gender, and so forth
Title 1 – General Provisions (U.S. State Code): General Provisions, Statutory Construction and Codification