In common law cases the appellate court could ordinarilyย review only rulings of law. In equity cases, on the other hand, theย appellate court could review findings of fact as well as conclusions ofย law. The significant thing about common law pleadings in error wasย that their scope was so limited that they did not bring about a reviewย of the merits of the judgment. The appellate court did not pass onย whether or not the judgment below was fair or just, nor on what theย correct judgment should have been. Instead, the sole question was,ย Did the trial judge commit an error? The function of an appellate court in reviewing equity cases, onย the other hand, is not to search the record for errors of law, but toย examine the result in the light of the evidence to see if justice has beenย done. Thus, the equity doctrine is in accord with the modern theoryย that the primary purpose of review is to see that justice is done in theย individual case.


More Stories
Counter-Claim under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908: History, Statutory Framework, and Judicial Evolution
A wilful act
Autopsy