M/S. METERS AND INSTRUMENTS PRIVATE LIMITEDย & ANR.ย VSย KANCHAN MEHTA[05-10-2017]
held :
In JIK Industries Ltd. vsย Amarlal Jumani โย which required consent of theย complainant for compounding
Vinay Devanna Nayak v. Ryot Sewa โnature of offence underย Section 138 primarily related to a civil wrong and the 2002ย amendment specifically made it compoundable.
R. Vijayan v. Baby (2012) 1 SCC 260โSection 357(1)(b) of the Cr. P.C. provides forย payment of compensation for the loss caused by the offence out ofย the fine
- Rajneesh Aggarwal v. Amit J. Bhallaโ(2001) 1 SCC 631Since theย concept of compounding involves consent of the complainant, thisย Court held that compounding could not be permitted merely byย unilateral payment, without the consent of both the parties.
- Mandvi Cooperative Bank Ltd. v.ย Nimesh B. Thakore(2010) 3 SCC 83, paras 25, 26 ย The object of Section 145(2) was simpler and swifter trial procedure.ย Only requirement is that the evidence must be admissible andย relevant. The affidavit could also prove documents. Affidavit of the complainant can be read as evidence.Bankโs slip orย memo of cheque dishonour can give rise to the presumption ofย dishonour of the cheque, unless and until that fact was disproved.
- Mandvi Cooperative Bank and J.V. Baharuni (supra) has broughtย about a change in law and it needs to be recognised. After 2002ย amendment, Section 143 of the Act confers implied power on theย Magistrate to discharge the accused if the complainant isย compensated to the satisfaction of the Court, where the accusedย tenders the cheque amount with interest and reasonable cost ofย litigation as assessed by the Court.
- Bhaskar Industries Ltd. vs Bhiwani Denim &ย Apparels Ltd-โthis Court considered the issue of hardship causedย in personal attendance by an accused particularly where accused isย located far away from the jurisdiction of the Court where theย complaint is filed. This Court held that even in absence of accused,ย evidence can be recorded in presence of counsel under Section 273ย Cr.P.C. and Section 317 Cr.P.C. permitted trial to be held in absenceย of accused.
- Court has jurisdiction under Section 357(3)ย Cr.P.C. to award suitable compensation withdefault sentence under Section 64 IPC and withย further powers of recovery under Section 431Cr.P.C.
We may, however, note that this Court held that generalย directions ought not to be issued which may deprive the Magistrateย to exercise power under Section 205 Cr.P.C.26 We need to clarifyย that the judgment of this Court is not a bar to issue directions whichย do not affect the exercise of power under Section 205, to require
personal attendance wherever necessary. Needless to say that theย judgment cannot be read as affecting the power of the High Courtย under Article 225 of the Constitution read with Articles 227 and 235ย to issue directions to subordinate courts without affecting theย prevailing statutory scheme.
Summary Trial
Once the complaint is filedย which is accompanied by the dishonored cheque and the bankโs slipย and the affidavit, the Court ought to issue summons. The service ofย summons can be by post/e-mail/courier and ought to be properlyย monitored. The summons ought to indicate that the accused couldย make specified payment by deposit in a particular account beforeย the specified date and inform the court and the complainant byย e-mail. In such a situation, he may not be required to appear if theย court is satisfied that the payment has not been duly made and ifย the complainant has no valid objection. If the accused is required toย appear, his statement ought to be recorded forthwith and the case
fixed for defence evidence, unless complainant’s witnesses areย recalled for examination.
Discharge Order to be issued
we hold that where the cheque amountย with interest and cost as assessed by the Court is paid by aย specified date, the Court is entitled to close the proceedings inย exercise of its powers under Section 143 of the Act read with Sectionย 258 Cr.P.C. As already observed, normal rule for trial of cases underย Chapter XVII of the Act is to follow the summary procedure andย summons trial procedure can be followed where sentence exceedingย one year may be necessary taking into account the fact thatย compensation under Section 357(3) Cr.P.C. with sentence of lessย than one year will not be adequate, having regard to the amount ofย cheque, conduct of the accused and other circumstances.


More Stories
Home Loan in US: Mortgage Rates, Types, Eligibility, Costs and Laws
Reverse Onus: Sec 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (1881)
Encyclopedia of Begging (6-Volume): A Global History of Asking, Giving, and Resource Acquisition