ADVOCATETANMOY LAW LIBRARY

Research & Library Database

Home ยป Sarvarthapedia ยป Law ยป Breach of Contract, Restitution, and Corrective Justice

Breach of Contract, Restitution, and Corrective Justice

The ordinary form of monetary relief for breach of contract is an award of damages, measured according to the position which the plaintiff would have occupied had the contract been performed. Correspondingly, the orthodox position maintained that disgorgement of the defendantโ€™s profits was not an available remedy for breach of contract.

The Syllabus

Restitution is the lawโ€™s remedial answer to circumstances in which a benefit moves from the plaintiff to the defendant, and the defendant is compelled to restore that benefit. Further, restitution stands in contrast to another measure of relief, disgorgement, which refers to awards that are calculated exclusively by reference to the defendantโ€™s wrongful gain, irrespective of whether it corresponds to damage suffered by the plaintiff and, indeed, irrespective of whether the plaintiff suffered damage at all.

The modern law of unjust enrichment originated in the writ of assumpsit (Peel (Regional Municipality) v. Canada, [1992] 3 S.C.R. 762, at pp. 786โ€‘88). The ordinary form of monetary relief for breach of contract is an award of damages, measured according to the position which the plaintiff would have occupied had the contract been performed. Correspondingly, the orthodox position maintained that disgorgement of the defendantโ€™s profits was not an available remedy for breach of contract. Disgorgement may be available for breach of contract in certain exceptional circumstances (Attorney General v. Blake, [2001] 1 A.C. 268 (H.L.); Bank of America, at paras. 25 and 30-31). In Blake, the defendant was a former member of the British secret intelligence service who had defected to become an agent for the Soviet Union. He was discovered and sentenced to 42 yearsโ€™ imprisonment, but escaped prison and fled the country. Blake later entered into a contract to publish his memoirs, in contravention of the confidentiality undertaking in his employment agreement with the intelligence service. The information in his memoirs was, however, โ€œno longer confidential, nor was its disclosure damaging to the public interestโ€ (p. 275). Further, Blakeโ€™s fiduciary obligations ceased to exist when he was dismissed from his post. The sole question was, therefore, whether the Crown could pursue disgorgement for his breach of contract.

Bibliography

American Law Institute. Restatement of the Law, Third: Restitution and Unjust Enrichment, vol. 2. St. Paul, Minn.: American Law Institute Publishers, 2011.

Barnett, Katy. Accounting for Profit for Breach of Contract: Theory and Practice. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2012.

Barton, Sandra, Mark Hines, and Shawn Therien. โ€œNeither Cause of Action nor Remedy: Doing Away with Waiver of Tortโ€, in Todd L. Archibald and Randell Scott Echlin, eds. Annual Review of Civil Litigation, 2015. Toronto: Carswell, 2015.

Beatson, J. โ€œThe Nature of Waiver of Tortโ€ (1978โ€‘1979), 17 U.W.O. L. Rev. 1.

Benson, Peter. โ€œContract as a Transfer of Ownershipโ€ (2007), 48 Wm. & Mary L. Rev. 1673.

Birks, Peter. โ€œRestitutionary damages for breach of contract: Snepp and the fusion of law and equityโ€ (1987), 4 L.M.C.L.Q. 421.

Botterell, Andrew. โ€œContractual Performance, Corrective Justice, and Disgorgement for Breach of Contractโ€ (2010), 16 Legal Theory 135.

Burrows, Andrew. The Law of Restitution, 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.

Canada. House of Commons. House of Commons Debates, vol. 2, 5th Sess., 13th Parl., April 11, 1921, pp. 1857โ€‘58.

Canada. House of Commons. House of Commons Debates, vol. 4, 5th Sess., 13th Parl., May 6, 1921, pp. 3005โ€‘6.

Canadian Oxford Dictionary, 2nd ed., by Katherine Barber, ed. Don Mills, Ont.: Oxford University Press, 2004, โ€œthreeโ€‘card monteโ€.

Cassels, Jamie, and Elizabeth Adjinโ€‘Tettey. Remedies: The Law of Damages, 3rd ed. Toronto: Irwin Law, 2014.

Chitty on Contracts, vol. I, General Principles, 33rd ed., by H. G. Beale, et al., eds. London: Sweet & Maxwell, 2018.

Edelman, James. Gainโ€‘Based Damages: Contract, Tort, Equity and Intellectual Property. Portland, Or.: Hart Publishing, 2002.

Edelman, James. McGregor on Damages, 20th ed. London: Sweet & Maxwell/Thomson Reuters, 2018.

Eisenberg, Melvin A. Foundational Principles of Contract Law. New York: Oxford University Press, 2018.

Friedmann, Daniel. โ€œRestitution for Wrongs: The Basis of Liabilityโ€, in W. R. Cornish, et al., eds. Restitution: Past, Present and Future: Essays in Honour of Gareth Jones. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 1998, 131.

Friedmann, Daniel. โ€œRestitution of Benefits Obtained Through the Appropriation of Property or the Commission of a Wrongโ€ (1980), 80 Colum. L. Rev. 504.

Gannage, Mark. โ€œNominal Damages for Breach of Contract in Canadaโ€ (2011), 69 The Advocate 833.

Hall, Geoff R. Canadian Contractual Interpretation Law, 3rd ed. Toronto: LexisNexis, 2016.

Iacobucci, Edward M., and Michael J. Trebilcock. โ€œAn Economic Analysis of Waiver of Tort in Negligence Actionsโ€ (2016), 66 U.T.L.J. 173.

Jones, Craig. โ€œPanacea or Pandemic: Comparing โ€˜Equitable Waiver of Tortโ€™ to โ€˜Aggregate Liabilityโ€™ in Cases of Mass Torts with Indeterminate Causationโ€ (2016), 2 Can. J. of Compar. & Contemp. L. 301.

Jones, Craig. โ€œThe Class Action as Public Lawโ€, in Janet Walker and Gary D. Watson, eds. Class Actions in Canada: Cases, Notes, and Materials. Toronto: Emond Montgomery Publications: Toronto, 2014, 28.

Maddaugh, Peter D., and John D. McCamus. The Law of Restitution, vol. 1. Toronto: Thomson Reuters, 2019 (looseโ€‘leaf updated December 2019, release 24).

Martin, J.M. โ€œWaiver of Tort: An Historical and Practical Studyโ€ (2012), 52 Can. Bus. L.J. 473.

McCamus, John D. โ€œDisgorgement for Breach of Contract: A Comparative Perspectiveโ€ (2003), 36 Loyola of Los Angeles L. Rev. 943.

McCamus, John D. โ€œWaiver of Tort: Is There a Limiting Principle?โ€ (2014), 55 Can. Bus. L.J. 333.

McInnes, Mitchell. โ€œGainโ€‘Based Relief for Breach of Contract: Attorney General v. Blakeโ€ (2001), 35 Can. Bus. L.J. 72.

McInnes, Mitchell. The Canadian Law of Unjust Enrichment and Restitution. Markham, Ont.: LexisNexis, 2014.

Oโ€™Hagan, Caraโ€‘Marie. โ€œRemediesโ€, in Lewis N. Klar, et al., eds., Remedies in Tort, vol. 4. Toronto: Thomson Reuters, 1987 (looseโ€‘leaf updated 2020, release 5).

Pitch, Harvin D., and Ronald M. Snyder. Damages for Breach of Contract, 2nd ed. Toronto: Thomson Reuters, 1989 (looseโ€‘leaf updated 2019, release 4),

Pitel, Stephen G. A., and Matthew B. Lerner. โ€œResolving Questions of Law: A Modern Approach to Rule 21โ€ (2014), 43 Adv. Q. 344.

Rosenberg, H. Michael. โ€œWaiving Goodbye: The Rise and Imminent Fall of Waiver of Tort in Class Proceedingsโ€ (2010), 6 Can. Class Action Rev. 37.

Sage, Nicholas W. โ€œDisgorgement: From Property to Contractโ€ (2016), 66 U.T.L.J. 244.

Sangiuliano, Anthony Robert. โ€œA Corrective Justice Account of Disgorgement for Breach of Contract by Analogy to Fiduciary Remediesโ€ (2016), 29 Can. J.L. & Jur. 149.

Sarna, Lazar. The Law of Declaratory Judgments, 4th ed. Toronto: Thomson Reuthers, 2016.

Sharpe, Robert J. โ€œCommercial Law Damages: Market Efficiency or Regulation of Behaviour?โ€, in The Law Society of Upper Canada, ed. Special Lectures 2005: The Modern Law of Damages. Toronto: Irwin Law, 2006, 327.

Sharpe, Robert J. Injunctions and Specific Performance, looseโ€‘leaf ed. Toronto: Thomson Reuters, 1992 (looseโ€‘leaf updated November 2019, release 28).

Smith, Lionel D. โ€œDisgorgement of the Profits of Breach of Contract: Property, Contract, and โ€˜Efficient Breachโ€™โ€ (1995), 24 Can. Bus. L.J. 121.

Smith, Lionel D. โ€œThe Province of the Law of Restitutionโ€ (1992), 71 Can. Bar. Rev. 672.

Stevens, Robert. Torts and Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Sullivan, Ruth. Sullivan on the Construction of Statutes, 6th ed. Markham, Ont.: LexisNexis, 2014.

Swan, Angela, Jackuk Adamski, and Annie Y. Na. Canadian Contract Law, 4th ed. Toronto: LexisNexis, 2018.

Virgo, Graham. The Principles of the Law of Restitution, 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.

Waddams, Stephen. Principle and Policy in Contract Law: Competing or Complementary Concepts? New York: Cambridge University Press, 2011.

Waddams, Stephen M. โ€œBreach of Contract and the Concept of Wrongdoingโ€ (2000), 12 S.C.L.R. (2d) 1.

Watterson, Stephen. โ€œGainโ€‘Based Remedies for Civil Wrongs in England and Walesโ€, in Ewoud Hondius and Andrรฉ Janssen, eds. Disgorgement of Profits: Gainโ€‘Based Remedies throughout the World, 29.

Weber, Greg. โ€œWaiver of Tort: Disgorgement Ex Nihiloโ€ (2014), 40 Queenโ€™s L.J. 389.

Weinrib, Ernest J. โ€œCausal Uncertaintyโ€ (2016), 36 Oxford J. Leg. Stud. 135.

Weinrib, Ernest J. โ€œPunishment and Disgorgement as Contract Remediesโ€ (2003), 78 Chi.โ€‘Kent L. Rev. 55.

Weinrib, Ernest J. โ€œRestitutionary Damages as Corrective Justiceโ€ (2000), 1 Theor. Inq. L. 1.

Weinrib, Ernest J. The Idea of Private Law, rev. ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.

Winterton, David. โ€œContract Theory and Gainโ€‘Based Recoveryโ€ (2013), 76 M.L.R. 1129.