
ROSY AND ANR. vsย STATE OF KERALA AND ORS. [ 10/01/2000]
I. (a) Under Section 200 Magistrate has jurisdiction to take cognizance ofย an offence oa the complaint after examining upon oath the complainant andย the witnesses present;ย (b) When the complaint is made in writing by a public servant acting orย purporting to act in discharge of his official duties, the Magistrate needย not examine the complainant and the witnesses.
(c) In such case Court may issue process or dismiss the complaint.
II. (a) The Magistrate instead of following the procedure stated above may,ย if he thinks fit, postpone the issue of process and hold inquiry for theย purpose of deciding whether or not there is sufficient ground forย proceeding against the person ac-cused. Such inquiry can be held by him orย by the police officer or by other person authorised by him.
(b) However, where it appears to the Magistrate that the offenceย complained of is triable exclusively by the court of Sessions, theย direction of investigation by the police officer is not permissible and heย is required to hold inquiry by himself. During that inquiry he may decideย to examine the witnesses on oath. At that stage, proviso further givesย direc-tions that he shall call upon the complainant to produce ย all his witnesses and examine them on oath. The reason obviously is that inย a private complaint, which is required to be com-mitted to the Sessionsย Court for trial, it would safeguard the interest of the accused and heย would not be taken by surprise at the time of trial and it would reveal the
version of the witnesses whose list is required to be filed by complainantย under Section 204 (2) before issuance of the process,
(c) The irregularity or non-compliance thereof would not vitiate the ย further proceeding in all cases. A person complain-ing of such irregularityย should raise objection at the earliest stage and he should point out howย prejudice is caused or is likely to be caused by not following the proviso, if he fails to raise such objection at the earliest stage. he is precludedย from raising such objection later.
It is pertinent to consider yet another aspect. It is of importance fromย practical point of view also. Section 209 of the Code enjoins on theย magistrate to commit the case to the Court of Session after complying withย the provisions in Section 208 of the Code. Once the case is committed itย proceeds to the next stage for which the venue is the Court of Session. Theย trial in the Court of Session is envisaged in Chapter XVIII. It must beย borne in mind that in the Sessions Court a public Prosecutor alone canย conduct prosecution, whether the case was instituted on police report or onย complaint. Section 226, falling within the aforesaid Chapter, requires theย public prosecutor to make the open address to the Sessions Court.
Private complaint case
If a case instituted on complaint is committed to the Court of Sessionย without complying with the requirements in clause (I) of Section 208 of theย Code how is it possible for the public prosecutor to know in advance whatย evidence he can adduce to prove the guilt of the accused? If no inquiryย under Section 202 in to be conducted, a magistrate who decides to proceedย only on the averments contained in the complaint filed by a public servantย (who is not a witness to the core allegation) and such a case is committedย to the Court of Session, its inevitable consequence would be that theย Sessions Judge has to axe down the case at the stage of Section 226 itselfย as the public prosecutor would then be helpless to state “by what evidenceย he proposes to prove the guilt of the accused”. If the offence is of aย serious nature or is of public importance the consequence then would be
miscar-riage of justice.


More Stories
Title 2 โ The Congress (U.S. State Code): Congress, Elections, Committees, Budget and Congressional Administration
1 U.S. Code Sec 1 – Words denoting number, gender, and so forth
Title 1 – General Provisions (U.S. State Code): General Provisions, Statutory Construction and Codification